This is the second time this has happened. I delete all my old posts and comments using PowerDeleteSuite. I view my profile - everything selected is gone. A few months later, it’s all back. I repeat the process, verifying it’s all gone. I log in today, months later, and it’s back. Simply maddening.
Is there anything I can do to make it stick?
afaik I’ve seen something called Redact which goes down to every post then overwrites the content.
That’s why some people have been modifying their comments entirely (and then deleting them).
This is what worked for me
Something is working because I’ve been sent to a few subreddits from search and half of the answers were gone. Made me happy that it stuck sometimes.
If you live in the EU maybe requesting full deletion of your account helps.
Unfortunately, they have no obligation to remove individual posts/comments unless they contain personally identifying information (iirc).
I’ve been manually deleting them, boring process for sure, but no restoring has been made.
I got like 15,000 comments tho.
I did the same two years ago. All content still deleted.
Wanted to make sure my deletions are not caught by some automated system so deleted posts and comments manually over the span of two weeks whenever I was waiting for something / had time.
Edit: added that this was 2 years ago
It’s not that it undeletes them, but that it keeps some of your comments unreachable. Every few months it re-indexes stuff and then with everything that was reachable before being deleted, it shows a different set of comments.
You can see more comments if you access the list with different params. For example, after deleting all your comments sorted by top score, you can access them sorted by controversial and you’ll see a whole other list of comments still there.
Yup. I remember reading something about this in another post a week or so ago. Reddit only lets you (or the bot doing the auto delete) see back through just about 1,000 comments or something along those lines.
Everything before that still exists but just isn’t accessible through your “Past Comments”, you’d actually have to find the threads themselves or like you said, re-sort the list so it indexs a different set of comments.
Do they delete them, or overwrite them?
Try overwriting instead.
That stopped working ages ago. They have everything backed up in a data base. It’s suspected they always had it so all those apps that would go and scramble you texts into nonsense didn’t matter since they could just sell the backups to llm and whoever else.
It’s widely accepted anything you typed into that website is saved in its entirety and by version
We also have claims of Reddit restoring scrambled AND deleted comments back to the original comment?
It’s not that it’s restored to original in the public facing reddit. Just that they have it and can sell it in its original form. Your web facing account only matters to web scrapers.
I’m assuming there’s a way to edit all your comments to say “Fuck Reddit” before deleting them.
Have you tried another deletion tool to make sure it’s not just a problem with the one you’re using?
The x89 python shreddit on github has worked for me, but it is a bit out of date and needs a little bit of tweaking to function. There is a new version (also on github) written in rust that also might work.
